1993

• First Team: Michelle Bills
• First Team: Misty Brinell

1994

• First Team: Chelsea Taylor
• First Team: Tamara Turner
• Honorable Mention: Heather Aichelle
• Honorable Mention: Kari Tracy
• Honorable Mention: Shannon Washburn

1995

• First Team: Tamara Turner
• First Team: Shannon Washburn
• Second Team: Shernada Fields
• Second Team: Pam Mungle
• Second Team: Dominique Savage

1996

• First Team: Mandy Coy
• First Team: Dominique Savage
• First Team: Quanna Speake
• Second Team: Lynn Sandfort
• Second Team: Kelly Barnard

1997

• First Team: Mandy Coy
• First Team: LaKesha DeBerry
• First Team: Quanna Speake
• Second Team: Angie Shockley

1998

• First Team: Laura Paul
• First Team: Angie Shockley
• First Team: Kristine Storey
• Second Team: Tracy Flora
• Second Team: Holly Morgan
• Second Team: Valerie Tomlin

1999

• First Team: Annesia Crawford
• First Team: Sara Kincaid
• Second Team: Tuamafa Reilly
• Second Team: Kimberly Wright
• Honorable Mention: Tracy Flora

2000

• First Team: Bea Gerevich
• First Team: Sara Kincaid
• First Team: Kimberly Wright
• Second Team: Tuamafa Reilly
• Second Team: Amanda Sherwood

2001

• First Team: Edna Chumo
• First Team: Bea Gerevich
• First Team: Amelia Langi
• First Team: Jennifer Mais
• Second Team: Petela Afungia

2002

• First Team: Edna Chumo
• First Team: Anna Dmowska
• First Team: Juliana Nogueira
• First Team: Roselidah Obunaga
• Second Team: Petela Afungia
• Second Team: Seini Tonga

2003

• First Team: Anna Dmowska
• First Team: Felicia Jones
• First Team: Juliana Nogueira
• First Team: Roselidah Obunaga
• First Team: Jaclyn Orlando

2004

• First Team: Felicia Jones
• First Team: Amy Lusk
• First Team: Jaclyn Orlando
• First Team: Candace Saleamua
• First Team: Maggie Thompson
• Second Team: Courtney Hendrickson

2005

• First Team: Courtney Hendrickson
• First Team: Luiza Jarocka
• First Team: Mafo Joelle
• First Team: Amy Lusk
• First Team: Candace Saleamua
• Second Team: Bethany Propst

2006

• First Team: Patricia Gandolfo
• First Team: Luiza Jarocka
• First Team: Mafo Joelle
• Second Team: Justina Begemann
• Second Team: Rachel Warrington

2007

• First Team: Patricia Gandolfo
• First Team: Brittney Herzog
• First Team: Monika Kasperek
• First Team: Rachel Warrington
• Second Team: Amanda Kuhn

2008

• First Team: Nile Whaley-Garrison
• First Team: Katja Stepanova
• First Team: Patricia Figueiredo
• First Team: Briana Walsh

2009

• First Team: Lindsay Hale
• First Team: Katja Stepanova
• First Team: Patricia Figueiredo
• First Team: Sabina Papala
• Second Team: Briana Walsh

2010

• First Team: Chloe Blount
• First Team: Lia Havili
• First Team: Janel Glidden
• First Team: Bianca Chatman
• Second Team: Goda Jankauskaite

2011

• First Team: Candyce Alexander
• First Team: Abby Hanger
• First Team: Magda Zietek
• First Team: Aerielle Edwards
• Honorable Mention: Bri’Ja Watterson

2012

• First Team: Helena Peric
• First Team: Taylor Swayzer
• First Team: Torika Baleiekutu
• First Team: Sarah Stretch
• Second Team: Candyce Alexander
• Second Team: Victoria Williams

2013

• First Team: Nella Ioramo
• First Team: Helena Peric
• First Team: Torika Baleiekutu
• First Team: Alyssa Aldag
• First Team: Lee Lee Barrett
• Second Team: Brianna Zebert

2014

• First Team: Gabby Edmondson
• First Team: Susannah Kelley
• First Team: Penny Liu
• First Team: Alyssa Aldag
• Second Team: Pulotu Manoa
• Second Team: Kaili Simmons

2015

• First Team: Gabby Edmondson
• First Team: Susannah Kelley
• First Team: Lotu Manoa
• First Team: Zori Curry
• Second Team: Autumn Reese
• Second Team: Stephanie Phillips

2017

• First Team:Kamryn Artale
• First Team: Tatjana Trifkovic
• First Team: Keziah Williams
• First Team: Grace Stumbaugh
• Second Team: Kinli Simmons
• Second Team: Koty Cooper

2018

• First Team: Kelly Wiedemann
• First Team: Julia Dunning
• First Team: Camilly Cristiny
• Second Team: Kamryn Artale
• Second Team: Tatjana Trifkovic

2019

• First Team: Kelly Wiedemann
• First Team: Maju Loureiro
• First Team: Camilly Cristiny
• Second Team: Emily Moore
• Second Team: Julia Dunning

2020-2021

• First Team: Maju Loureiro
• First Team: Lauren Weber
• First Team: Ruth Manuela Bibinbe
• Second Team: Imani Nicholson
• Second Team: Nayla Watkins

2021

• First Team: Ruth Manuela Bibinbe
• First Team: Doga Kutlu
• First Team: Lauren Weber
• First Team: Ilana Assis
• Second Team: Cecilia Westfall
• Second Team: Alana Moesch